Friday, February 18, 2011

Workshop Grades: The Fifty-Point Scale

For this semester's workshop assignments, I grade in 5-pt intervals based on a fifty-point scale.  Before worrying too much about how the scale will affect your grade, I'd like you to consider how I use the scale to tell you about your writing.


Creative Writing: Can I Really Write the "50-pt" Story or Poem?
 50 points is very difficult to achieve, even for me. On a good day, I usually write fiction around a 40 - I can usually revise my own stories to a 45 and sometimes a 50. Writing poetry, I usually start somewhere between 30-40, but it's much harder for me to revise my poetry to a 45 - I don't know that I've ever written a poem that would earn a 50. But I have read a few IFP poems of that caliber, and I've also read a few IFP stories of that caliber.

I tell you this because writing is a continuous process for each of us, regardless of level or experience.  "Writing a 50" isn't simply a matter of "this person is a '50-pt Writer.'"  Writing the 50-pt story is a question of the characterization, conflict, attention to detail, and careful revision applied to the individual story.  You'll note that in the grading below, I categorize each grade not only by the quality of the work, but also by what stage of the writing process the story is in.  A story that receives a lower grade isn't necessarily a worse story - it may simply be that the story needs more work before it reaches its full potential.


Please note that your overall course grade is not based simply on the individual stories.  Instead you are graded on your overall progress as a writer.  I give rough drafts 100% (10/10) because writing a rough draft is one of the most important parts of improving as a writer. Honestly, I would rather grade workshop pieces that way, too, but it isn't fair to hand out grades at the end of a writing course without giving some early indication of your progress as a writer.  The other major component of your progress as a writer comes in your ability to read and discuss literature, and this is evaluated through the quizzes and your participation grades.

As IFP 2 students, most of your writing grades will probably be starting somewhere in the 20-40 range.  Yes, this is a broad range - from past experience, I've seen that most groups of students have a broad range of natural ability and learned talent.  My goal is to see each of you reach the 35-45 range in your writing by the end of the semester.

Now, I understand the temptation to think "45 is 90%, and that's only an A-..."  Please avoid this.  Letter grade percentages only really work when considering your overall course grades.  I've purposefully boosted the value of the rough drafts in order to give lower grades on the writing assignments - it's the only way I could possibly differentiate between someone writing at the Jane Austen/Emily Dickinson level (really, really good - usually in the 50's or even 60's) from someone writing at the John Grisham/Danielle Steele level (also really good, but not quite that good - maybe 45's?).  And we haven't even considered authors like Vonnegut (40-55?), Shakespeare (45-55?), J.K. Rowling (45-50? 60+?), Sylvia Plath (55?), or Stephenie Meyer (35? 45? 55+? 6i*3x^2?).

Just remember - writing is hard work, but it comes with many intrinsic rewards.  And the best writers - every writer, in fact - is born illiterate.  Except maybe Stephen King.  I'm pretty sure he was doing Princeton Review in the womb.  And also note that every story is different.  Some of the best stories have no dialogue at all - sometimes, they might have no setting, or possibly no characters.  Granted, these are exceptions, but they illustrate one important rule about the grading scale: it's an inexact science.


2 comments:

  1. First, the bottle face of a replica Rolex is fabricated of cartier replica azure clear that can alone be aching by a diamond. Thus, a replica will never get scratches even with connected use admitting a affected one will absolutely be abounding of scratches afterwards a few months of abuse. If you are able to do so, try abrading the bottle face if blockage out a replica. Do accomplish abiding that you will not be answerable should you appear to breitling replica blemish a affected wristwatch. However, you cannot do this if you are affairs online. A money-back agreement can be your best aegis if it comes to this situation. Second, Swiss watches are accepted for their absorption and superb craftsmanship. A Rolex replica should accept easily that move smoothly, as if they are flowing. A hasty minute duke is a assurance that what you accept is a fake. Even while manufacturers accept fabricated it their job to imitate the aboriginal as best as they can, it is this aspect with the easily that they accept not yet begin a band-aid for to http://www.ukrolexreplicass.uk.com this day. Third, replica watches will accept a hologram-encoded sticker on the aback of the watch. They aswell buck a altered advertence amount and aloft such amount is addition hologram of the brand is logo. Affected ones may aswell accept these stickers but they are affected holograms such that they do not change actualization if beheld from a altered angle.It is a actuality that affected Swiss watch manufacturers are accepting bigger anniversary day in agreement of assuming the original. So if in doubt, you accept no added best but to accessible the aback of the rolex replica watch. If you are affairs from a absolute replica watches distributor, they would alone be too blessed to do this for you. There are aswell models that accept cellophane aback covers to let you see the absolute wonders accident central a wristwatch. The Internet is abundant with sellers that affirmation to be affairs accurate replica watches. To abstain getting swindled, accomplish abiding that you analysis the website and see if it has a aboveboard acceptability if it comes to online selling. If affairs from accepted sites such as eBay, analysis the seller is ratings and apprehend some of the latest feedbacks. This will accord you an abstraction how annoyed the buyers are. Aswell attending for a money-back agreement as this is your surest way of replica watches uk alive if they advertise accurate appurtenances or not. They consistently buy from their accustomed dealer, but then, just for that one piece, they bankrupt down and went to an crooked antecedent on the Internet. And abiding enough, they got burned. They paid $20,000, $25,000. What they got, de Quervain says, was a counterfeit.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In which write-up permits totally outstanding information and the enjoy it designed for offering kinds experience with us. Now click on the following Check Cashing Enjoy it regarding fantastic process as well as thank you.

    ReplyDelete